Shutterfly Versus Vistaprint

Note: We receive a commission for purchases made through the links on this site. Our sponsors, however, do not influence our editorial content in any way.

This Vistaprint and Shutterfly photo book review covers everything you need to know in order to decide which photo book printing service is right for you. Is Vistaprint good for choosing various themes, layouts and colors? Does Shutterfly have templates to choose from? Read on and explore our Shutterfly vs Vistaprint review today.

Shutterfly got started in 1999, so it had plenty of time to create great products before many other companies even formed. The photo book has been the company’s flagship product for several years. Many people choose to make photo books with Shutterfly because they are familiar with the company. They know that the business does good work, so they feel comfortable using it to make personal photo books.

Storing images on a hard drive, CD or DVD might seem like a convenient option, but many people miss the opportunity to hold photos in their hands. The digital revolution will never change that. With Shutterfly, people can create photo books that memorialize important events, such as weddings and graduation days.

Today, many companies offer services that are similar to Shutterfly’s. Browse their options before you determine which company can make the best photo book at the right price for you.

How Does Shutterfly Photo Books Work?

Shutterfly gives you three ways to make a photo book. The Make My Book service takes all of the work off of your hands. Once you upload the pictures that you want included in your book, a professional designer will create a layout that brings the images to life. It takes about three days for the designer to make your book. It’s free to get started, though, if you want to check out the service before paying any money. You only have to pay when you decide to order a book.

The Custom Path option lets you create your own photo book from scratch. Shutterfly gives you access to all of its backgrounds, layouts and other embellishments that you might want to include. You also get to add text to any or all of the pages.

Custom Path is a good option for people who want to take control over their photo book projects. If you have some graphic design experience, then you may find that Custom Path gives you something fun to do over the weekend. Even if you don’t have any experience with graphic design, Shutterfly’s online software makes it relatively easy for you to add the pictures, texts and decorations that you want.

The Simple Path is your easiest way to make a photo book without paying a professional designer to do the work for you. Simple Path gives you 40 styles with preset layouts and backgrounds. Once you choose the style that you want, you simply add your pictures (up to 30 per page). Simple Path can arrange pictures for you, but it does so randomly. If you let Simple Path arrange your photos, you will probably want to go back to rearrange or replace some of them.

After creating the inside of your book, you choose additional features that will make it a unique item. Many of the additional features cost extra money, so pay attention to your total price as you customize your project. Then, Shutterfly can get to work making your book. Within a week or so (depending on the delivery method you choose), your new book will arrive.

What Makes Shutterfly Photo Books Stand Out?

Shutterfly Photo Books stand out by offering such a wide variety of printing and packaging options. Many companies only let you choose between two or three types of paper for your covers and pages. Shutterfly has a large catalog that you can use to personalize your photo books.

It’s also important to note that Shutterfly has a lot of experience in this area. The publishing company has been printing photo books since 1999. Over the years, Shutterfly has learned effective ways to print high-quality books without charging high prices. That helps make it one of the most popular photo book publishers on the internet.

Common Reviews of Shutterfly Photo Books

Practically everyone who uses Shutterfly to make photo books seems to love the service. Reviewers point to the high quality of the photos, binding, covers and pages as proof that Shutterfly does a better job than most printers. A lot of people also like that the company has so many options to add to their books. This doesn’t just include upgraded jackets and paper. It also includes clip art and themes that can turn drab books into fun objects that you’ll want to leave on the living room table for guests to browse.

Of course, you can always find some negative reviews. Even the best companies make mistakes. A handful of unhappy customers complain that they did not receive their photo books by the expected dates. A late delivery could matter a lot to someone who plans to give photo books away as presents. If the package doesn’t arrive by the right time, then you won’t have gifts for your special event. Shutterfly and other companies need to realize that delivery times make a difference to their customers.

Other than missing some delivery deadlines, Shutterfly gets stellar reviews from everyone who uses the company’s photo book services.

Is Shutterfly Photo Books for Me?

In most cases, Shutterfly is a good choice for people who want to print personal photo books. The company has affordable prices and excellent books, so practically anyone will enjoy using their services.

If you’re a professional, however, you may want to look for a photo book publisher that offers additional services. That’s especially true for professionals and experienced amateurs who plan to sell their photo books to consumers. There are other companies that will print professional photo books and help you sell them online through a variety of websites. A casual consumer wouldn’t want to use these companies. Someone with professional or commercial aspirations, however, should choose one of those companies over Shutterfly.

For the most part, though, Shutterfly is one of the best photo book publishers that you can choose. Of course, you should always compare prices and options from several companies before you decide to use Shutterfly. Most people, however, quickly discover that Shutterfly offers some of the best deals on the types of photo book services that they want.

About the Author

Jeff Hindenach

Jeff Hindenach is the co-founder of Versus Reviews. He graduated from Bowling Green State University with a Bachelor's Degree in Journalism. He has a long history of journalism, with a background writing for newspapers such as the San Jose Mercury News and San Francisco Examiner, as well as writing for The Huffington Post, New York Times, Business Insider, CNBC, Newsday and The Street. He believes in giving readers the tools they need to get out of debt.

What Is Vistaprint?

Vistaprint is a business that can help create photo books, business cards, and more. This organization has been around since the late 1990s, so it has had plenty of time to develop its services. Instead of expanding this service, Vistaprint has decided to stick to the basics. This approach means that practically anyone can design an attractive book using Vistaprint. Unfortunately, it also means that you have limited options when creating your book. Don’t expect to find a lot of extras. Instead, you’ll get a straightforward photo book with high-quality prints and a sturdy build.

How Does Vistaprint Photo Books Work?

Vistaprint makes it very easy to create photo books. Once you navigate to the site, you choose a layout that appeals to you. You then upload images that you want to add to your Vistaprint photo book. You can also get images from your Facebook timeline. You can choose to place one image on each page, or you choose the collage option that lets you place up to six images on each page.

Vistaprint has a very simple layout feature. Even newcomers should find it relatively easy to use. If you don’t want to spend time putting your book together, though, you can pay $5 to have someone at Vistaprint do the work for you.

Once you complete your book, Vistaprint makes your copies and sends them to you via the mail or another courier service.

Vistaprint Return Policy

If you are unsatisfied with your product, the Vistaprint return policy is to either reprint your product or issue an account credit to completely refund the customer. Shipping for new products will be covered by Vistaprint. To ensure requests are properly handled, Customer Support should be contacted by phone at 1-866-614-8002, email, or live chat on the Vistaprint website. Make sure you contact Vistaprint within 30 days of receiving your order.

What Makes Vistaprint Photo Books Stand Out?

Many people like Vistaprint because it charges low prices for its photo books. You can buy a basic, 20-page book for just $10 plus shipping and handling. You won’t find many companies that offer deals like that.

The prices do go up a bit depending on what you want to add to your basic photo book. Even with extras, you still get a good price. Vistaprint only charges 50 cents for each extra page that you want to add to your book. You could barely print a photo on a home printer without spending 50 cents. Vistaprint photo books keep the price low without sacrificing the quality of its product.

Common Vistaprint Reviews

Consumers have a lot of mixed emotions about photo books from Vistaprint. Many people praise the company for keeping its costs so low. Some people also point out in Vistaprint reviews that the site works well for them because they feel intimidated by design software with too many options. Vistaprint makes graphic design as easy as possible, so you can understand why those people prefer using Vistaprint.

Happy customers say that Vistaprint has friendly customer service representatives who want to solve problems. It helps that Vistaprint gives you three ways to contact customer service. It’s also nice that the company has a customer service center that stays open seven days a week. As long as you call during the right hours, you should get to speak to someone within a few minutes. No one complains of lengthy wait times.

On the other side, you have Vistaprint reviews that complain everything is kept too simple. The online software won’t let them develop creative designs that use different camera angles, image filters and a variety of materials. Instead, you get a plain book with pictures in it. While some people love this aspect, others hate it. They want to find an option that will let them get more creative. In fact, many customers say that they would rather pay higher prices if it meant getting more options.

Unfortunately, you may have to accept that Vistaprint’s low prices force the company to offer limited services and products. The publisher could give you more options, but it would have to charge more money. While some people say that they wouldn’t mind paying more, the company clearly wants to target budget-conscious consumers who like taking advantage of good deals.

Some people complain that Vistaprint often misses delivery dates. This may not matter much to you if you just want to have a book that preserves some of your favorite photographs. It will matter a lot more if you plan to give the photo books away as gifts. If you have a deadline to meet, then you should make sure that you give Vistaprint plenty of time to make your book and put it in the mail. Also, you should choose a shipping option that matches your expectations. Some people get upset when they choose the cheapest shipping option but don’t get their packages within a few days.

Are Vistaprint Photo Books for Me?

Vistaprint photo books aren’t for everyone. If you want a highly creative, professional-looking book, then you may want to try a different company. Extremely creative people who find joy in unique items probably won’t love the photo books that Vistaprint makes. Luckily, there are plenty of publishers that are willing to let you do just about anything for enough money.

On the other hand, Vistaprint is an excellent option for people who want basic photo books that don’t cost much money. You’ll have a hard time finding a better deal than the one Vistaprint gives you. If you don’t care about fancy upgrades, then you should check out Vistaprint’s photo book site to see if it’s the right option for you.

Vistaprint has found a niche audience of consumers who want to save money without sacrificing quality. Think of it as going to a nice restaurant with affordable prices instead of going to a gourmet restaurant with outrageous prices. You’ll still get a good product, you just won’t pay as much for a unique experience.

About the Author

Jeff Hindenach

Jeff Hindenach is the co-founder of Versus Reviews. He graduated from Bowling Green State University with a Bachelor's Degree in Journalism. He has a long history of journalism, with a background writing for newspapers such as the San Jose Mercury News and San Francisco Examiner, as well as writing for The Huffington Post, New York Times, Business Insider, CNBC, Newsday and The Street. He believes in giving readers the tools they need to get out of debt.